Mike Westerdal is joined by Steve Ohocinski and Tim Nixon to explore why Columbus Day and Indigenous Peoples’ Day have become a point of division and what the debate reveals about the way we view history, identity, and one another.
Mike, Steve, and Tim examine the difference between celebrating a historical achievement and endorsing every action of the person behind it. From Columbus’s voyages and Italian American heritage to the contributions of Indigenous peoples, they consider whether both stories can be recognized without turning the holiday into a competition.
The conversation then turns toward colonization, slavery, and the challenges of judging historical figures through a modern lens. With candid opinions and plenty of humor, the three discuss changing cultural standards, the role of activists and media in shaping public debate, and why acknowledging the failures of the past doesn’t have to mean dismissing every accomplishment.
One of the central themes of the conversation is learning to approach history honestly, recognizing both its achievements and its harms while asking what we are actually choosing to celebrate.
As the episode comes to a close, the discussion returns to a question that reaches beyond the calendar: Are we looking for reasons to come together, or more reasons to stay divided? Mike, Steve, and Tim share their thoughts on honoring both holidays and using the conversation as an opportunity to talk about history with the next generation.
Timestamps
00:00 – Why are these two holidays on the same date?
00:32 – Welcome to the Strong by Design podcast!
00:58 – Join hosts Mike Westerdal, Stephen Ohocinski, and Tim Nixon for today’s special episode
01:23 – An unexpected mix of Indigenous and Italian ancestry
02:04 – The New York City encounter over Columbus
04:14 – Why do these holidays share the same Monday?
06:07 – Columbus, colonization, and historical controversy
08:32 – Did Columbus really discover America?
10:46 – Do holidays unite us or divide us?
13:41 – Can we separate achievements from human flaws?
17:31 – The debate over names and changing standards
20:01 – Are we judging history by today’s standards?
23:40 – The dangers of crossing the Atlantic
26:09 – Would separating the holidays solve the debate?
28:55 – Can America still celebrate together?
31:54 – Teaching history without turning it into a battleground
32:40 – Share, rate & review the Strong by Design podcast!
Connect w/ Critical Bench:
